Green light on slouchy trousers: what footwear?

So I finally got a chance to show hubby the slouchy trousers. He likes them a lot and was not negatively impacted by the back view.

So I've finally decided for sure to keep them and am off to the alterationist to get them shortened!

But I'm not convinced that my Marcies are the right footwear for these, at least on me. They feel a bit clunky with the wedge and the laces sort of impede the fabric's drape. I feel I need a bit of a heel....I am all for long bodies and all that, know...I am a bit self-conscious about the short legs.

Should I be looking for a heeled shootie/ bootie? What would work best?

This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.


  • Karie replied 10 years ago

    Oh I like these! A nice black and white shoe like Angie had in one of her recent outfit blogs would look great. I also think a heeled shootie would look nice. A bootie might get in the way with the fabric at the hem, similar to what your shoe laces do.

    I like the way your styled it in your photos. I have a shirt similar to #1 and #2, I think I am now in the market for black slouchy trousers! Where did you get yours, if you don't mind me asking?

  • rae replied 10 years ago

    I don't like my slouchy trousers with my Marcies, either. Have you tried them with the Marks booties?

  • Laura replied 10 years ago

    I agree, Suz - think you will feel better with heeled shoes. I wore mine with animal patterned pumps and felt fab.

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    Well I guess I'm alone in liking my slouchy trousers with my Marcies! But I do hear what you're saying about the fabric drape.

    Have you tried them with your Doc Sara oxfords? And like Rae, I suggest trying them with the your Marks booties. And you also have the DV booties - correct? What about those?

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Thank you, ladies!

    Karie, I got these trousers at Winner's (like your TJ Maxx) in what they call the Runway section. They are by a Danish designer called Noir. You can find good slouchy trousers at Zara, though. And Laura created her own by buying petites and sizing way UP at Ann Taylor.

    Shannon, I do have my Saras. (Karie, these are a black and white oxford with a heel, sort of like what you are suggesting.)

    But you know what? I am thinking of passing my Saras on to a YLF friend.

    I am finding them too big for me (physically...they are about a half size too large) and also visually, in many outifts...including with the slouchy trousers. I think Angie's thoughts on that were dead on. I am semi in the market for another saddle or spectator style shoe, a bit more refined than the Saras. Because I love that style, generally, and always, always have. But I expect I might have better luck with that in spring.

    They don't work withe the Reports because of the bootie's wide opening. Also, the colours seem a bit extreme....the black wool with the light sand suede. I COULD do it in a pinch. Because of bookending.

    They look "okay" with the smog DVs, but not great...the DVs are really too casual for them. Again, it sort of works due to bookending with my hair, but it's not ideal.

    I DO have leopard print pumps and I can try those. Thank you, Laura! They are a wedge heel, too, though, so might not work.

    Would something like this be good to try?

    or maybe this one, similar?

    I've never actually owned a true shootie.

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    Oh that's too bad about the Saras - but if they aren't working for you then there is no point in keeping them.

    I like both of these shooties and think either could work with these trousers, plus many others bottoms as well.

  • Sara L. replied 10 years ago

    I agree that the shoes you're wearing with the trousers aren't quite right. Both pairs of booties look like they would work better. I prefer the first pair but the second pair is simpler and might be better for not competing with the pants.

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    I adore these pants on you, Suz. As for the Doc Saras, that was my issue too - the big round white toe just felt too MUCH with skirts somehow, maybe because I have such scrawny legs, and with pants it just looked like I was wearing white shoes, which is so not me. Yet Shannon rocks her pair all the time! Variety is the spice of life!

  • krishnidoux replied 10 years ago

    I like these trousers so much on you! Wonderful! And from Winners at that. You are so lucky. I love how you have styled them. You are right about the shoes. Have you tried with you J.S. booties? The heel is well defined in those. Otherwise I would go for a classic, delicate heeled pump. Do you have a pair? If not, maybe look for one. It would look so good with your dressy menswear inspired outfits. And don't think they shouldn't be comfortable, if well chosen they can be very wearable.
    ETA: just looked at your Clarks ideas, yes, I've tried those and one pair was comfortable, the other not (can't remember which!). You have to try them in a store.ETA ETA: these were very very nice:

  • Sveta replied 10 years ago

    Suz, I love the trousers! What a great find - at Winners? Wow!
    I wear my slouchy trousers with both booties and pumps. I think your wedge animal pumps will look great with them.
    I find that I love my both pairs of SE Petty booties with my trousers - python print and putty. They have elongated toe and look quite refined with this style even though the heel is 1 1/2" only. Maybe you should consider them now?:-)

  • RunnerChick replied 10 years ago

    I really like look of the trousers with the Marcies as you have them styled here. I think the Marcies give the outfit a hip, cool edge. But, if you're feeling less than great about it, well, that's an argument for considering a different option. I like the idea of this outfit with a leopard pump. I think red (or even cobalt) might be feasible options too, but that might be too predictable. Have you considered heeled loafers? Some of the styles are quite funky (in a good way)...

  • Raisin replied 10 years ago

    Suz I really don't know what shoes would be best, but I had to say I really like that blouse with them, and just on its own. I've been looking for something similar.

  • merwoman replied 10 years ago

    just having a chuckle - "not negatively impacted" SO wants to know what I'm laughing at, not sure he would understand :-)
    Love the pants. I also thought about those report booties. Even though the colour(s) might not be right - I find it helpful to try on most of my footwear to get a sense of what style of shoe/shootie/bootie I should be looking for.

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    Oohhhhh Sveta - great idea about the python Sam Edelman booties. Suz...what do you think?

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    I LOVE the shape of those Sam Edelman booties and had indeed thought about them...but I think I might want a higher heel.

    The nice thing about these pants though is that they really are quite tapered at the bottom so perhaps it doesn't matter....I can get them hemmed and they should probably work with pretty much all heel heights. I did think it would make most sense to hem them for the shoes I'll probably wear most, though....

    Hmmm...wish I could try the Pettys on someplace rather than doing the online ordering thing.

    Krish, I DID try with my Siebels and I do think they look better than with the Marcies, but still not 100%. I would perhaps wear them with those, but would like to have some options.

    Good point, Merwoman....I will try again with the Reports just to make sure my eyes were not deceiving me.

    Una, you are so right....I LOVED my Saras when I first bought them and did get some good wear from them, and they have taught me that I need a spectator style shoe in my wardrobe....I just love that graphic punch! But these are probably not the ones for me, long term.

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    In terms of spectator style shoes Suz, have you considered the tri-tone patent Jeffrey Campbell's like I have? They are a chunky 2 inch heel and are almost more versatile because they don't have the white toe - the toe is taupe!

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    I have indeed considered them, Shannon - I admire them so much on you and Christie. Are they comfortable?

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    They are very comfortable - but I would say border on a bit narrow. I have medium width feet and find these "just" fit. I wouldn't want them any narrower. But I wear them for 8 hour days no problem. I wear a 6/6.5 and bought them in a 6.5.

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Thanks, Shannon - that is helpful. I would probably go with my larger-end size then. The reviews are so mixed on the comfort that I wasn't sure....

    I'm strongly considering them.....

    I like the patent aspect, too.

  • Jaime replied 10 years ago

    I don't have any shoe advice - I rather like the docs actually. But I do want to reaffirm my love for your slouchy trousers!

You need to be logged in to comment