Tonal Dressing Experiments: Greyscale

Taking inspiration from DonnaF's  thread about sweater vests, and one of Carla's comments on my thread of yesterday: "When I did a lot of quilting, we talked about patterns that read as solids, and how much interest low contrast or tonal prints added to a composition. Of course it would be the same with garments! Maybe even a good thing, where texture is lacking?"    

Well, let's see. Here, I'm trying it in greys. This is something a bit tricky for me. Grey is a key neutral and looks good on me (I think) but I can easily depress myself if I wear too much of it, especially this time of year! But the sun is supposed to come out this afternoon, and I have to ride my bike downtown. I wanted something practical. 

The pants are charcoal, not black, and they have a faint check in a lighter grey. The shirt is black and white gingham that can read as a false plain (but gives me that pop of light that I crave). So it's a very subtle pattern mix. The vest is medium grey, as are the boots.

Strangely enough, I do not own a grey coat (I donated my two older grey coats in the last few years. They still fit and were in good condition after a decade's solid use, but I was so tired of wearing them.) This oyster jacket has a slight grey cast and is the best I could do for greyish outerwear. If I were not trying this experiment, I would certainly have reached for the red jacket instead! 

If I weren't on my bike, I could have worn different boots for perhaps a bit more pizzazz. But I do feel very much myself in this outfit -- it does fit the Laid-back Luminous Garçonne persona due to the boyish nature of the vest and shirt, I think. 

Here's a collection of other items I can play with in greyscale. If i veer toward pure white, I would have more. 

I welcome comments and co-experimenters! 







1
2
3
4
This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.

17 Comments

  • Angie replied 1 month ago

    KILLER cute, Suz

    I think the reason you feel like yourself despite the tonal greyscale is because: 

    • you added the HIGH contrast white in the gingham
    • you added the HIGH contrast and SHINE in the puffer and bag
    These elements make you the luminous garçonne feel and look radiant :)

  • slim cat replied 1 month ago

    Very nice! I can't do grey - washes me out completely but that oyster jacket is perfect for making the neutral outfit sing ( great bag as well - love metallics )!

  • Jenni NZ replied 1 month ago

    Looks good! I like the pants. I love to have some kind of subtle pattern in pants rather than totally plain. Perhaps why my olive snakeskin ones are still my faves.
    I find I feel more subdued in winter and I am often happy in greys, black and white etc. I only crave the pops of colour sometimes then.
    I know what you mean about feeling just *so tired* of certain items. It happens to me too. So far I have not regretted editing out a few things that way, if they have had good use.

  • Jaime replied 1 month ago

    Yes to what Angie said above. My first thought was this is more like how I would do tonal - sort of high contrast tonal. Although I think the pants read darker in the first few photos (at least on my screen) than they seem in the closeup shot.
    Anyway, this is an excellent outfit and suits you beautifully!

  • Dee replied 1 month ago

    Another fab version of tonal dressing. I think the subtle mix of patterns is another great way to do it. There's a certain elegance to it all when its done in the same colour family.

  • Brooklyn replied 1 month ago

    Totally love this! Would you wear it again? I think it’s fabulous.

  • Firecracker (Sharan) replied 1 month ago

    You nailed another tonal outfit, Suz. I love this combo on you. And I was nodding to Angie's analysis of how your touches of white and shine really make it yours.

  • Suz replied 1 month ago

    Sharan -- so true. It's the bits of white (and silver, I guess) and having those close to my face that seems to make it feel wearable. 

    Brooklyn, I would definitely wear this again! It was easy to wear. I think the bit of pattern (and the white) helped it feel more "me." But also, the pieces individually and as an outfit worked extremely practically for my actual day -- which as you know is key! 

    Dee, yes, I agree. The pattern mix (especially because it is so quiet and subtle) comes across as subdued and therefore elegant. 

    Jaime -- the pants look a bit darker in the first photos than in real life, and a lot lighter in the last photo than in real life. They're  charcoal grey. 

    Jenni, those snakeskin pants are so fab. And yes, I agree, a subtle pattern in pants makes them so much more fun. 

    Slim cat -- thank you! What is "your" grey, do you think? 

    Angie, thank you. I do agree that the addition of greater contrast makes it feel more like me. So interesting! 

  • Lisa replied 1 month ago

    You look lovely in tonal grey and the additional whites and pattern add a nice touch.

    Those boots are truly fabulous, love the multiple buckles on them.

  • Kate replied 1 month ago

    Totally love this, and do grayscale myself with small houndstooth check top when I wear light gray & oyster white.

  • Bijou replied 1 month ago

    I love the waistcoat, perfect on you!

  • Janet replied 1 month ago

    The vest is so great! This is my kind of tonal dressing. Well done.

  • JAileen replied 1 month ago

    Okay, I love this.  I love grey and I love your style.  That vest is just too cute!  


    I have a lot of grey, and I’ve often said if it were removed from my wardrobe, I might not be able to get dressed.  I used to have those same snake pattern boots.  I found them hard to style and so donated them.  It’s probably because I have such big feet.

    BTW, I have four grey coats that I can think of off the top of my head..

  • Angie replied 1 month ago

    InStyle today:

    https://www.instyle.com/gray-o.....ace&d

  • Carol replied 1 month ago

    I love it. What a fun challenge. And I do see the Luminous Garconne--in fact, that outfit looks like something a woman would wear in a French New Wave film. 

  • Suz replied 1 month ago

    Thanks, Carol! Jean Seberg is an icon for me! 

    Angie, great ideas! No surprise I like the suit best of all. I need a tie, hmmmm.....

    Thanks, JAileen. Yes, you are probably the Queen of Grey on the forum! Let's see those grey coats in action! Do you get depressed wearing it? But I think your winters are sunnier than mine in the PNW. 

    Janet, the version with coat and bag especially reminds me of you!

    Thanks, Bijou, Kate, Lisa. 

  • SarahD8 replied 2 weeks ago

    I love the subtle pattern mix here!
    The other thing that strikes me is the contrast between a more dressy trouser and vest silhouette, and the casual/workwear vibe of the gingham shirt.
    So maybe dynamism can sometimes come from contrast in register/formality, rather than color?
    This outfit is reminding me of some looks from a brand called Nygårdsanna that keeps popping up in my Pinterest feed (Pinterest is being wonky for me at the moment but you can search if you're curious).

You need to be logged in to comment