More boots: Alternative to Sorels?

Okay, okay. I know I have already bought 3 pair of boots this year. Two of those are even waterproof...and one has some insulation. But it's still primarily a fashion boot. 

I also own a 5 year old pair  of Clarks riding style boots, with thinsulate (or similar) lining. They are "warm enough" commuting type boots. But they are no longer waterproof and can't be made waterproof, it seems. (Believe me....I have tried treating them to no avail; water seeps in anyway -- though they are fine in dry snow.) 

In addition, I own a pair of gear hiking snow boots -- short -- good in extreme temperatures, but too clunky and obviously gear-ish to wear in town, plus snow tends to fall into the tops -- which isn't an issue when the rest of your outfit is gear, but is when it is regular clothing. 

Usually the Clark's would do fine for the kind of snow that tends to linger here in town. But with the slush, the ice, the freezing rain, and the continuing snow, this winter is killing me, and I feel I need something really weatherproof and warmer. 

I just went and tried on the Sorels. No go. The Joan of Arctic style is just terrible (way too wide) on my foot. The Tofino is better but still far too wide at the heel. 

Anyone have a good suggestion of alternatives to try where the fit is "neater." Style is less important in the sense that I am open to a variety of looks for this purpose. But they should be waterproof, WARM, and not the kind of boot I have to be super careful of. 

I looked at some Uggs but didn't like the styles they had at this store. Glory has recommended Pajar to me in the past. I could check Ecco, too, since they give me a good fit. But other ideas welcome. 

Thank you! 

This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.

34 Comments

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    Kamiks. They are crazy-warm, roomy for thick socks, waterproof, lightweight, durable and pretty cute for the amount of function. Also won't break the bank.

  • karymk replied 10 years ago

    I must leave this to the arctic fabbers....

  • Krista replied 10 years ago

    Suz, what about Bogs or Kamiks? Very warm, very weatherproof and they come in a variety of styles.  My husband has them in plain black and when he wears them with jeans (without jeans tucked in), they look kind of like a Chelsea boot.

    I have Kamiks because I too found Sorels too wide.  I popped an insole into the Kamik and they fit like a glove.  When I'm done with my Kamiks, I'm getting a pair of black Bogs like my husband has.

    ETA: I see I cross-posted with Una! :)

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Oooh! Thank you! I just saw your Kamik comment on Carla's thread, Una! Are the New Yorks TTS? I have found them on sale at SoftMoc in 3 colours. Debating between red and grey....or maybe black....all look great! 

    Thank you, Krista! It's great to have your recommendation, too. They look exactly like what I need, actually, and are a good price. 

  • Diana replied 10 years ago

    Are blondos not warm enough? Sveta says she wears hers in the snow. Anyway I tried these on yesterday and liked them enough to order the black:
    http://www.blondo.ca/en/produc.....er/vitalia

    Calf on those is probably too big for you though but you could look at other styles. Not all the styles have the lug sole though, which I think is necessary for snow.

    Otherwise, my snow boots are sorels. But my feet are like yours, narrow especially at the heel. Mine are a discontinued style called sorelia Earhart. The foot is narrower then most sorels and the laces mean the ankles arent ginormous. Still a few sizes left on amazon:
    http://www.amazon.com/Sorel-Wo.....sbs_shoe_5

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    The 6 is perfect on my short wide high arch feet. They are not tall, more like mid-calf, but really warm and unless I'm slogging through feet of snow they are good for everything. Also grippy. I found Bogs slippery and uncomfortable for my arches - they pressed on the top of my foot and cut off circulation. Also they got stiff in cold weather. My kid loves his Bogs though.

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Diana, I think there are different types of Blondo boot, and some would be more snow worthy than others. Most of them are similar to my old Clark's, though -- okay for short commutes if you are moving constantly and temperatures are reasonably okay, but not a true snow boot. 

    I will check out those Sorels of yours -- thank you! But I dimly remember trying on a bunch of other Sorel styles the year I bought my snow gear boots and none of them fit right. 

  • Diana replied 10 years ago

    Yeah, I wouldn't wear the Vitalias in an actual snowstorm or to shovel snow, but I think they'll be good for walking around when there's still snow and ice on the sidewalks.

  • Tania replied 10 years ago

    Bogs are a winter standard around here (Southern NH, arty/crafty/farming community).  Kamiks are great as well. 

    Just in case...I just purchased Sorel 1964's (duck boot type), which seem more fitted than my old Sorels.  I had intended on looking at Kamiks, but these were on sale at a local store.  They have a removable liner and are -25 rated, which works for me.  They also were fitted enough with super skinny jeans and didn't look too big on my size 9 narrowish feet/narrow lower calf.  My first outing with them garnered a couple of comments on how they were nice and sleek, but that was coming from people that owned the bigger Sorel Caribou boots.  I popped a sheepskin insole into them because my foot prefers natural fibers (the felt liner isn't wool).  Anyway, there is just enough space for thick socks, a liner, and to allow for warmth (if a boot is too tight, it won't keep the foot warm).  If you are interested, I can take a picture on my foot/lower leg.

    Tania 

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Yeah. Well, that is what my Clark's were for...and worked for...until this year. 

    It's partly that they lost their waterproof properties, so that makes them risky to wear. I have to admit that. But they're also not feeling warm enough for our current temps and the combination of wet snow, dry snow, ice, and freezing rain. Maybe the insulation on these is also shot...hmmmm. Could be I just need a new pair of similar boots. You have a point there. 

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Thank you, Tania. No need to take a pic (though I am delighted to look!) :) But I will take a look for that style when I am in the city in a few days. 

  • replied 10 years ago

    I saw Kamik Quests 50% off at Canadian Tire today. They also had the taller Kamiks too.

  • goldenpig replied 10 years ago

    I like my Born Zunigas!
    http://goldenpig.lookfab.com/p.....r-princess
    I'm going to test them out at Tahoe...

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    One more pitch for the Kamiks - I wear them when I fear getting stuck somewhere, like in the insanely cold dark mountain pass we drive through to our cabin. I do not have to WORRY about wet or cold feet when I wear them, and frankly that is worth everything to me. :)

  • Diana replied 10 years ago

    Oh!  Just remembered I had saved these in my Amazon cart.  They were from Angie's polyvore a couple of days ago.  

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/produ.....PDKIKX0DER

  • JAileen replied 10 years ago

    Can you get Timberland in Canada? They have waterproof boots in a variety of styles. I have 2 pairs and love them. I especially like their traction, and that they're not huge like Sorels.

  • ironkurtin replied 10 years ago

    Are Keens dressy enough?

  • lyn* replied 10 years ago

    Have you tried the North Face? I love my boots I have from them, but they are 3-4 years old. 

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Lyn - thank you! I will check out North Face. 

    Keen would be fine, depending on the style, Dana. I will look. Thanks!

    Timberland is also possible, Aileen. I had a pair of theirs that didn't fit me so well but they came from consignment so may have moulded to the other person's foot. In all other respects I loved them! But they weren't warm enough as winter boots. Great for autumn. 

    Natalie -- I am sure the same would be true for those Borns. They are super cute but not weather boots for where I live. Ditto for the Cole Haan's, Diana, I suspect I am looking for something more truly SNOWboot, you know? The Kamiks look ideal. Now to try them on!

  • Jaime replied 10 years ago

    Well I have nothing to say but Happy New Year on this one!

  • Glory replied 10 years ago

    Suz I feel your need on this one. The perfect winter boot is waterproof, warm, light weight and not so clunky that you cannot drive! I have a pair of snow boots that I bought years ago to play outdoor with the kids but I cannot walk in them and driving would be almost illegal.
    The pajars this year have had terrible problems with poor traction which is a no go in our weather.
    I am also looking for the perfect snow boot. I bought the snow queen from Marks but returned it because I did not like how the top flared out. 
    I am now going to check the Kamik - I didn't realize they were warm! Thanks Ladies who have recommended. I cannot wear any of the Sorels, and I find Bogs much to heavy and they get wet in side.
    Globo has a few kamiks but they also have Superfit. I purchased a pair of superfits for my youngest child last year and she loved them. They only lasted one season but that doesn't really reflect on the boot - she is one hard playing child.
    Globo also carries the New York but they call it Inez. Here is another that might work:
    http://www.globoshoes.com/ca-e.....-anezka/12

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    These are mine but in grey - http://www.zappos.com/kamik-new-york-dark-red

  • Jjsloane replied 10 years ago

    Past needing my input, but kamiks would have been my suggestion too. Excited to see what you choose, I need these rarely but have 3 pair of Sorels and an ancient pair of ll bean duckboots. 

  • Joy replied 10 years ago

    Suz, I had these Blondos on my feet and they were gorgeous but still too wide in the calf for me but narrower than most. They are waterproof and not too high.
    http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/bl.....ts-_-1_4_B
    They are a great deal on sale and look much like these Aquatalias, also a great choice but pricey.
    http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/aq.....ts-_-1_8_C

  • Joy replied 10 years ago

    Suz, my warmest snow boots are hush Puppies. These seem good looking and weatherproof:
    http://www.dsw.com/shoe/hush+p.....06,cat2017
    However you may be better off getting a better quality.

  • replied 10 years ago

    I just got the Kamik Seattle from zappos today. They are teeny tiny!

    http://www.zappos.com/kamik-seattle-charcoal

    I normally wear a 7 1/2 and ordered a 8 in these. I think I would have to order a 10 for them to fit in the length with warm socks on. Not sure if I got an off pair or not. They claim to be rated for -40.

  • replied 10 years ago

    I wanted to mention that I just shoveled snow in my Columbia boots and my feet stayed warm and dry.

    I got them last year so I am not sure of the model but they look something like this:

    http://www.zappos.com/columbia.....dovan-tusk

    They ran small.

  • kkards replied 10 years ago

    I missed this post earlier. If you aren't looking for style, but are focused on waterproof and warm, I recommend the bean boots lined with shearling.

    http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop.....ling-lined

  • Sam replied 10 years ago

    I've mentioned them before, but I finally pulled the trigger on the Baffin Madeleine's and I really like them. They keep my feet warm (bot not uncomfortably so), snug, and dry. They have pretty decent traction, too, although that was just on snow. Haven't tested them on ice yet, but I suspect that they're not going to change my "I will do anything to avoid walking on ice" stance. 

  • Aubergine replied 10 years ago

    My snowboots are actually kids' Timberlands. They're these, only the fabric inserts are black/brown tweed:
    http://www.zappos.com/timberla.....t-big-kid-

    They're relatively fitted in the calves and definitely look more like regular riding boots than hard-core snowboots. They've held up pretty well for me in terms of traction and warmth, although my winters aren't nearly Canadian-level and I frankly only need to wear them a few times a year. Even though they're kids', they look like they go up into the equivalent of medium-sized women's sizes.

  • April replied 10 years ago

    Suz, did you find your winter boots?  I'm looking too.  The pair I have right now somehow transmit the cold directly to my feet -- not exactly what anyone is after in a snow boot.

    I've been looking at these http://www.sierratradingpost.c.....rFamily=01, but they're only available in a 7.  That's my size, not sure if it's yours.

  • Jules replied 10 years ago

    I'll be taking a look at the gear suggestions myself so thanks for starting this thread. Just chiming in to say I know what you mean about once-trusty boots that cannot be relaunched. My experience has been that once breached, boots cannot be brought back to waterproof state! I know the sinking feeling of realizing my boots have sprung a leak and will never be the same again!
    *yes, I worked on my boat metaphors for a minute or two :)

  • Glory replied 10 years ago

    Suz I just ordered the Kamik's that Una recommeded. I tried them in the store but they only had the grey left and I preferred the black. I did go up a size but a half size would have been perfect. I ordered them from Globo - online they are called Inez but the box is marked New York.
    They are very light weight and cozy on. They should arrive Monday so fingers crossed.

  • replied 10 years ago

    I have a pair of very abnoxious Earth boots, that I love for the snow. They make a bunch of less over the top styles. There is something with the incline of the shoe that is not everyone's cuppa but I like it fine.

You need to be logged in to comment