I'm hoping you'll indulge me in a little analysis. This, by the way, is all in the service of my new year's goal about distilling the essence.
Here you see two recent and very similar outfits. Both skirt, sweater, boots, and scarf. Both fairly monochromatic.
Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to tell me:
Which do you think works better for me...and why.
Note, I'm not asking you to say which is the better outfit in some abstract sense.
I have my thoughts and theories but I would like to hear yours first.
Please vote for Team 1 (Yay) or Team 2 (Nay), and no sitting on the bench -- it is freezing cold there with none of Angie's delicious snacks.
Thank you for your help!
ETA: Added a pic of #1 without scarf. Different footwear (different time of year) but it helps give a slightly different impression of how it actually looked if you put the two together.