Wardrobe inventory: Some unexpected discoveries

Ingunn's recent reflections about the extent of her purchasing this year set me into action yesterday. Instead of just wondering and worrying about how much I'd bought and how much I'd spent, I decided to do some actual counting. 

And I learned something quite interesting. 

Despite the (what seems to me) extraordinary amount of shopping and trying on I've done this autumn, I've actually purchased and kept relatively little -- especially when compared to what I retired, donated, and consigned. In other words, if you're going on the one-in-one-out principle (and using girl math) -- there's lots of room for more buying here. ;) 

Without going into the dollar figures, here, so far, are the stats: 

Total items by category bought F/W:             
1 skirt
2 dresses   (or 1?)                                             
1 bag                                                                          
5 footwear                                                           
6 sweaters                                                           
2 shirts                                                                 
1 jacket (2 or 3?)                                                 
1 pant (??)
   

                                                                        

Total items by category eliminated
1 dress
1 bag
5 footwear
7 sweaters
5 shirts
6 jackets                                                                            
1 tunic
1 pants
1 jeans
1 coat
1 outerwear jacket                                                      
3 layering tops
                                                                              

I'm leaving out a few items bought during the fall, but primarily for transitional and/ or summer wear, such as my striped VC tube skirt and the Kamalikulture dresses. These all got a fair bit of wear already but I won't be wearing them in the colder weather and have put them away for the season. 

I'm also leaving out items that I purged at the end of last winter. In other words, I got rid of even more -- I just can't remember it all now. Whatever I got rid of in the spring would have been truly worn out or unusable for some other reason. 

Also not mentioned are items I bought but returned either immediately (for the NAS - some I tried on and eliminated in the change room) or later (several NAS items like one of the Halogen skirts, the Pleione crossover top, etc., and some Zara items and BR items that I've tried but sent back.) So if you're thinking, "Wait a minute...she had more than that!!" -- keep in mind that I did send some of it back. ;)

The question marks represent a few items I'm still undecided about. A dress that may go back to Nordstrom's (I'll post about it separately), the Lanai, the BR tux jacket, the BR plaid pants -- none of which I'm absolutely sure of. 

In looking at the pieces I've eliminated, I'm happy to say that only two represented what I would call "shopping mistakes," and even those two got wear. I used them four or five times each last F/W or spring, and then donated to someone who would get more value from them. (The Leith pants went to Mo, the teal tunic went to my stepdaughter.)

Of the other items, almost everything else was worn out. Some items had actual wear spots!  Others had been worn steadily for two or three seasons (or in the case of some poor quality sweaters, one) and were well past their prime.

One or two things that went to my stepdaughter were not worn out, but I'd worn them "to death" -- e.g. my H&M fuchsia cropped jacket. I just couldn't wear it any more. She also got the BR denim shirt that I wore all the time last year but never loved.  

The jackets that I've purged  (except for the H&M) were lovely wool jackets bought on consignment. They weren't worn out, exactly; they were such high quality they'll probably never wear out! But the styles felt even more dated than when purchased 3 seasons ago, and Angie spoke, I listened. ;) 

So. That's my summary of where I'm at. I still think that purchasing 20 items for one season is a lot -- and I know myself too well to think I'm absolutely done my buying.

But I do feel good about what I've bought and kept. And even on a $$ basis, it has not been unreasonable. The price of two pairs of boots ensures that it hasn't been a cheap F/W -- but nor has it been wildly extravagant. And I am calling the boots my birthday present from my mother, who always gives me a bit of cash to buy something . 

Some reflections (and please feel free to stop reading at any time!!)

The skirt (a plum Halogen seamed skirt) is a great addition to my city/ travel capsule. I had wanted a coloured skirt for some time. 

The dress I know I'm keeping (the blue David Meister) is a fantastic core LBD purchased on substantial sale. 

The bag is a practical size in a good for me neutral. And was purchased at Winner's at about 60% off the retail price. 

The footwear was required: two fall/ winter tall boots that are weatherproof, one dressy and one casual/ dressy; two booties, one in navy and one in cranberry (I had no coloured booties); one pointy toed shootie for dressier occasions. (I had no dressy alternatives for pants.) The booties I got at the NAS so the prices were reduced. 

The sweaters have all already seen a ton of wear. I have realized that in my work-at-home winter capsule, knitwear is my friend, and purchasing five to eight sweaters a year (depending on the wear on the ones I have and how many I need to update) is not at all extravagant or foolish, given a CPW calculation. I like and need some variety in this capsule or I go mad with boredom. And knitwear requires frequent updating -- there's no way around it. It just looks tired a lot faster. 

In fact, I've also discovered, to my astonishment, that I might even want some interesting cardigans in this capsule! I am so not a cardigan girl when I'm out in the world -- I love my jackets!! But at home, some interesting and/ or avant guard cardigans could be super useful to me. 

The shirts that I bought are not crisp button downs but more casual options -- a new chambray shirt and a knit shirt. Again, this is smarter for transitional work-at-home wear for me. I don't wear crisp wovens at home in winter. I like them better in spring and summer, or when out and about in winter. 

The jacket I know I'm keeping (the Zara jacquard) has already got a ton of wear. Super purchase for me -- has earned its keep already. 

Okay. That's it for now. If you've read this whole saga, you're a saint. But -- how about you? 

  • How much have you actually kept (compared to what you've tried out)?
  • And how do you feel about your purchases? 
This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.

27 Comments

  • viva replied 10 years ago

    I'm feeling better about my spending.
    :)
    Seriously, I am going to my closet this afternoon and will do an inventory as well, Suz. I think you are right to think in terms of pieces and wear. I do return a lot of what I buy although I try to do less online ordering now, as my developing romance with the UPS man was really annoying my husband. But also because my online shopping tends to be impulsive and not thought-out. I'll report back with some thoughts!

  • Parsley replied 10 years ago

    I'm with you, Suz, as far as feeling like I've done nothing but buy, but the truth is that I also feel like I've done nothing but return!
    It's a pain being PPP! But of course there is the reward in the end of having a wardrobe you love.
    It sounds like you have done well with your shopping this year, and have replaced things that needed to be replaced.

  • Kristin L replied 10 years ago

    Bravo Suz! I'm still doing my wardrobe purge (I just uploaded about 10 things on my swap site). Doesn't it feel great, though, to realize that you don't need things? I feel like I've been buying more than normal, but I feel like that's ok since I have a new job and a new dress code. 

  • Liz A. replied 10 years ago

    I know I've done a lot of shopping, and it is so tempting to keep pieces that are almost right just to balance the sheer amount of energy and time put into the endeavor. PPP is definitely something I need to work on.

  • Angie replied 10 years ago

    *APPLAUSE*

    You love analysis Suz, and we enjoy reading your eloquent, intelligent, and down to earth thoughts. 

    You've done a great job keeping your purchasing on the straight and narrow and catering to your needs. Most people don't come close to this type of wardrobe success - and I know you had fun along the way. AND wear what you bought. Well done. 

    NB: Remember that when you buy stuff online - the return rate is very high. How can it not be? 

    I buy fewer, more expensive pieces generally, (excluding my Zara flirtations which in itself is a fun process and in line with my high-low style). As a result, I never seem to purchase in quantity - although I do spend my budget. My budget does not buy me quantity. I usually buy one piece for the price of 3 to 5 "average price" pieces (again that's very relative because budgets are relative). Anyway, it's one reason why my wardrobe is relatively small. Plus I edit with the one-in-one-out principle. I'm not saying my strategy is best. But it works for me. Just like Suz, your strategy works for you. 

  • Beth Ann replied 10 years ago

    I know that sometimes it seemed like everything you tried was "almost, but not quite," but I think you've done brilliantly at refining your style and your wardrobe needs this season.  Not only have very few of your purchases been "mistakes," your outfits are so consistently fab -- the mark of someone coming "into their own."  How nice to take stock of your purchasing and realize that you accomplished all of this while remaining fiscally responsible!

     I just did a bit of inventory, too, Suz, but only with sweaters.  I've actually purchased 8 --- yes 8 in the past 6 months.  A couple of cardis are in that number, and they're mostly more casual, layering pieces.  As you know, I've been boosting my home/lounge wear, buying simple, economical pieces that focus on a newer fit and often, a beautiful color.  I'm finding that being framed by a lovely teal, purple, burgundy or rich sapphire (I think I'd like to actually shop for a blue a twinge deeper than cobalt), is a great mood lifter for me.  I catch my reflection in the bathroom mirror and know I look my best.  I'm still looking for a couple of warmer "cuddly" sweaters, particularly a great looking, artsy cardi --- I'll let you know if I see something in my search that would work for "cool writer at her desk" wear!

  • Mo replied 10 years ago

    Seems very reasonable to me!  I'm at 27 pieces for the entire year, but have not kept track of the purges as well as you have.  
    Just this last week or two I have really just gotten tired of the placeholders and the almosts for around the house.  I've been altering to try and help with pesky fit issues and usually purging shortly after, when that doesn't solve things.  
    My lesson is that my 'stay at home' capsule is lacking.  I need a step up from the loungewear that's more fit to wear to bed to bridge my true going out into the world clothes.  Hence, the red jersey dress I recently got.  I think 3 more pieces like that would go a long way towards making my at home attire both comfortable and versatile, in that it can also go for simple errands if paired with a 'real' item, some jewelry and shoes for instance.
     
       

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Mo, what you say makes a ton of sense. I, too, look for items in my "at home" capsule that can be "finished" with a jacket or some accessories and go out the door, but that feel comfy and easy while in the house. 

    And you are amazing at 27 items for the year!

    Beth Ann - love the idea of some framing cardigans in best colours. And 8 sweaters does not sound excessive to me. In our climate, we wear them. 

    Angie, I really like your strategy best!! And I think once I (finally) determine my real core essentials, it will be easier to put into practice. That's why I need my suit! :-) I'm getting much closer. In future years I would like to keep things to maybe 6-10 "update" purchases per year, perhaps excluding the sweaters, which wear so quickly and do need replacement when they wear. 

    Liz, Marcy, you're right that PPP takes enormous energy and time. 

    K - if you have a new job, you naturally have new needs! 

    Viva -- looking forward to hearing your reflections!

  • Marmee replied 10 years ago

    Suz, what is PPP?  I tried to do a search, and found lots of references to it, but no definition.

    Considering going through my closet this afternoon to find out how many items I've purchased this year, although I've put my summer things in the attic, as my closet is so tiny.

  • Mo replied 10 years ago

    http://youlookfab.com/2012/01/.....principle/

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    PPP is Angie's dictum: Patient, Picky, and Practical. 

    It takes patience to wait for the items we want or need. We need to be picky about fit and about cut and style -- not just colour (which used to be the thing I gravitated towards, ignoring other important features). And practical is obvious -- if it doesn't fit our lifestyle, we won't wear it. 

  • Marmee replied 10 years ago

    Thank you Mo and Suz!  This is good for me to remember.  Sometimes I feel pressured by salespeople, but it will be easier to resist if I remember this.

  • Isabel replied 10 years ago

    Wow.  This is awesome, Suz.  And as someone who follows you, you seem to be making fantastic choices that suit you extremely well. It would be interesting to know what the percentage of use and happiness was for what you gave away. I am willing to bet it was really low.

    I have not bought much this year since I completely revamped my wardrobe 18 months ago. Practically from scratch because of body changes. ( yeah, yeah, yeah...I gained a TON of weight.  LOL )  But last year, my rate of returns was really, really high.  To the point that I was feeling sorry for stores, I am not kidding. 
    For me, I am starting to trust my gut about what I love.  I don't really settle anymore. But I am realistic about my lifestyle and budget.  The part of my wardrobe that I am thrilled most about are my shoes/boots.  They are sooooo comfy and nice looking.  I swoon.  

    The only thing that I think I really need are a bootcut pair of jeans now.  

    I loved reading this post by the way.  I have a weird affinity for wardrobe dissections.  :  ) 

  • Transcona Shannon replied 10 years ago

    Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant!!! And you have inspired me to just do the same thing :)

  • Caro in Oz replied 10 years ago

    Loved reading this Suz. I hear you & Mo about the at home capsule.  I purged all my clothes in this category that were not working so now even my cleaning outfit is something I love. It has made such a difference to how I feel about my clothes & it forces me to wear my "good" stuff everyday.

  • Peri replied 10 years ago

    I like what you said about sweaters. That really applies to me too as they are all I wear in the winter. I'm not a jacket person...they feel restrictive to me with my broad shoulders, especially at the piano. Hearing it worded like you did...that it is a very reasonable expense...really perked me up! Most of mine are so old that even if they don't look tired, they make me feel tired. I really need a new sweater wardrobe...now if I could just find ones I like that aren't wool.

    I'm currently a revolving door with my shopping too. So many returns, not really all that many purchases. But that's not so new for me, I think I am hard to please. Or PPP is a nicer way to look at it.

  • Joy replied 10 years ago

    Suz and Ingunn, I applaud you both. I failed miserably at 12 in 12 months, but maybe next year. I really want to add a few low end pieces that are fun and trendy to update; but improve the quality of my basics. To that end I've done better. I count 46 purchases this year plus a couple of tube skirts thatbi'm still trying to make a decision about. By far most of my purchases were jeans in colors other than blue and updates that are more boyfriendy. Plus I wear them daily.
    The other big area was summer dresses replacing many thrifted ones. I gave away several bags to a couple of young mom's and sent some things to the thrift store ( probably where they came from).
    I hope to get to where Angie is soon, just needing a few pieces each season to update. I'm getting better at PPP and make most buying mistakes when I'm not Patient enough or Picky enough to buy better quality. Overall, I feel like I'm making progress. Lots and lots of returns get made.
    .

  • Sveta replied 10 years ago

    Suz, this was such an useful exercise. I went and counted mine (lemming, I know) and came up with 25 cool season items for clothing and footwear which were added this year (from January). I did not count what I got read of but as the size of my wardrobe is pretty consistent and I practice "one in-one out" diligently now I know that I at least broke even (and still have some "free spots" for blazers I did not manage to get this year. The only one I made an exception for this rule was the long coat as it was a hole and  was looking for one for 3 years.
    BTW, did you return Aquiatalia boots or kept them? I remember you wanted to keep them because you despaired to find knee high ones...
    Mind you there are more of warm season items as well but they are not counted here :-)

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    Sveta, I like your calculations, and I know you have been very careful about what you buy. You definitely helped keep me on the straight and narrow at NAS! As for the long coat, that was a superb purchase you will not regret. 

    I have put the Aquatalias in a box to return. I think with two knee high boots I am really set. Truthfully, the mid-calf height just wasn't calling me and while they are absolutely stunning boots, I think if I really want a quick-on-quick -off flat heeled casual boot I would probably feel more love for a flat Chelsea boot with similar impermeability and weather proofing. So I will send these back and see whether I find anything on sale in the late winter. In the meantime, I now have knee high boots to wear. (Yay!)

    I'm also debating the Tory Burch dress. Even on sale it is a big expense and I have not worn it yet; nor do I see myself wearing in the foreseeable future. So it seems as if it might make sense to send it back, much as I love it. I am much more likely to wear the (heavily discounted) Lanai and enjoy it (even if not perfect and not a suit) than I am to wear the TB dress. 

  • Sveta replied 10 years ago

    I think it is  a wise move on the boots: I also find this height hard to wear except with dark skinnies. I am sure between 2 pairs of LC boots and all you booties you are all covered.
    I see what you mean about TB dress. It is gorgeous and looked great on you but if you feel you will not get much wear out of it it is wise to return: better than having an expensive orphan. And please don't settle for a heavy discounted Lanai because it is not perfect for you: you deserve better ()this is my bossy self trying to keep you on the straight and narrow again :-) )
    BTW, did you order a certain blazer from HR this weekend with the discount?

  • Lantana replied 10 years ago

    Suz I love wardrobe dissections and yours inspired me to do my own count. I have bought new 8 coolweather items and have worn and worn every single one of them. Skinnies@2, polonecks@2, striped tunics@2, black booties and a drape sweater.
    I have not counted underwear, which has had a major overhaul post-YLF, or thrifted items. The latter are for playful practice, an economical way for me to try new looks. If they don't work out I send them back to the "op shop".

  • Suz replied 10 years ago

    No, Sveta, I did not order anything, but perhaps I will look at the site and consider....hmmmm. Okay...off to peruse. And you're right about the Lanai, I know. It's in the box to go back. Just dithering....

    Penny -- that sounds incredibly careful of you - 8 items only! Amazing. You made superb purchases. 

    And I agree about thrifted items. My whole first year on YLF I pretty much bought only thrifted or consigned items as "practice." (Apart from jeans, that is). And it worked out pretty well. But it's also a big reason why I am still purging so much. Many of those items turned out to have a shorter shelf life in my own closet, either because they wore out more quickly or because they appeared dated sooner. 

  • Lantana replied 10 years ago

    Suz it's true, I am careful but the fact is I only need casual clothes for half a day. Mornings are spent outdoors doing hard yakka (well, hard for me) so I'm decked out in steelcapped boots and workwear until hunger, heat or fatigue drives me inside.

  • Jaime replied 10 years ago

    Just an aside, my thrifting is mostly reduced to stuff to re-sell, stuff for someone else and workout or lounge things occasionally. I have upgraded to consignment for my personal thrill of the hunt. I am beginning to think I need to pay more attention to my in and out - my wardrobe is in such a state a flux I actually would have no idea how to begin a list like this. Anyway, Suz, the main thing is you are so control of your style right now and you look consistently fab!

  • Ariadne replied 10 years ago

    Fascinating and inspiring.  This makes me want to keep closer tabs on my purchases in 2014.

    ETA You're really thinking about returning the TB dress?  I loved it on you SO SO SO MUCH.

  • catgirl replied 10 years ago

    What I have kept compared to what I have TRIED seems minimal.  But I've actually kept quite a bit.  On the other hand, I have transitioned to such a new situation that I'm giving myself leeway to experiment while at the same time trying not to stray outside my known comfort zone.  Not easy!  I'm also spending more on fewer items. 

    Hmmm, I'm not good at keeping track but I will have to inventory this week since I have the week off!

  • Karie replied 10 years ago

    Great post, Suz. There are definitely more items going out of my wardrobe right now than are going in (but there are quite a few going in, LOL). I am attempting to hone in on my individual style and not just buy because it fits and the price is right. 
    Because of my job and my climate, most of my clothing purchases happen at this time of the year. This year, I have done more on-line shopping because when I see or hear about something that fits well, and is well made, and fits with my style goals, I'll give it a try. If it doesn't meet with PPP, back it goes. And A LOT has gone back. With practically everyone offering free shipping both ways, and living a stone's throw from every major retailer (except Nordie's, go figure), there is no reason not to be fussy. 
    So this year I stayed on budget except for one impulse purchase - a gorgeous polka dot (how could I resist?) purse. I swear the store owners know when I am coming by and put all polka dot merchandise in my path. What's a dotty lover to do?

You need to be logged in to comment